Claims Against Developer-Controlled HOAs and Master Associations

Some associations are run for the people who control them rather than the owners who pay for them. In a hotel-condominium tower, a mixed-use building, a resort, or a fractional or residence-club property, the developer, a hotel owner or another commercial owner often appoints a majority of the master association's board, picks its manager, and sells it services. That control can be used to move costs onto the residential owners, pay affiliated vendors without scrutiny, and fund the controlling owner's business through the association's budget and reserves.

Reiser Law, P.C. represents sub-associations, independent directors and owner groups in claims against the developers, affiliated companies, managers and directors who use an association this way. We handle these cases in California and Florida state courts, in federal court, and in the arbitration that many governing documents require. We take association-wide matters in which the overcharges or diverted funds are substantial, and we do not handle individual owner disputes (see below).

The claims we pursue

Misallocated shared expenses. The declaration usually fixes how shared costs are split between a hotel or commercial component and the residential components. We see boards controlled by the commercial owner depart from those percentages, bill utilities and other "allocated" expenses directly to the residential components but not to their own, and justify the change with a decades-old resolution adopted before any independent director was seated.

Affiliate billing. The hotel operator or another affiliate provides security, janitorial, engineering or maintenance labor to the association and invoices it monthly, often with a labor factor or markup and little detail. When the invoices are approved by directors affiliated with the same company, the association can end up paying for staff who serve the hotel, the restaurants or the retail tenants.

Reserves that fund private business assets. Reserve studies sometimes include equipment the association does not own, such as reservation systems, garage equipment in a separately owned unit, or hotel finishes. Owners fund those reserves through their assessments.

Self-dealing contracts. No-bid consulting, project management and management agreements with the developer or its affiliates, approved outside a noticed meeting or over the objection of the independent directors.

Construction defect recoveries. Developers sometimes take an assignment of the association's defect claims, recover a large settlement, and then control how much of it is spent on repairs and how much goes to fees, consultants and the developer's own share.

Governance failures that hide the numbers. No adopted budget, no audited or reviewed financial statements, unfiled tax returns, and records requests that go unanswered. These are often the first signs that the money will not survive a close look.

Fractional and condo-hotel programs. A developer that controls a fractional club, residence club or condo-hotel rental program can use the association to subsidize its sales program, carry retained inventory at a discount, or shift operating costs to owners. Our page on fractional interest and timeshare litigation covers related claims.

The duties at stake

In California, directors who are a developer's agents or employees owe the association and its members undivided loyalty, and they may not make decisions for the association, including decisions on maintenance contracts and the operating budget, that serve the developer's interests at the members' expense. Raven's Cove Townhomes, Inc. v. Knuppe Dev. Co., 114 Cal. App. 3d 783, 799 (1981). In an action to enforce the governing documents, the prevailing party recovers reasonable attorney's fees and costs. Cal. Civ. Code § 5975(c).

In Florida, the officers and directors of a condominium association have a fiduciary relationship to the unit owners, and the officers and directors of a homeowners' association have a fiduciary relationship to the members the association serves. Fla. Stat. §§ 718.111(1)(a), 720.303(1) (2026).

Claims against the developer, its affiliates and the controlling directors can include breach of fiduciary duty, breach of the declaration, fraud and concealment, recovery of improper payments, rescission of affiliate contracts, an accounting, and, where the conduct supports it, punitive damages. Many master declarations require arbitration between the associations, but they often allow a court to grant interim relief while the arbitration proceeds.

Who brings these claims

The claims usually belong to an association, so the client is often a sub-association board, or independent directors acting for the owners they represent. Owner groups can also sue directly or derivatively, depending on whose injury it is and what the governing documents allow. Sorting that out early decides who must be named, what must happen before filing, and who recovers.

How we build the case

  1. Get the records. Directors and members have statutory inspection rights in both states. We use them to obtain invoices, contracts, budgets, reserve studies, bank statements and minutes.
  2. Rebuild the money. We compare what each component paid against the allocation percentages in the declaration, trace affiliate invoices to the work actually done, and test each reserve line item against what the association owns, working with forensic accountants where the numbers call for it.
  3. Read the governing documents closely. Allocation provisions, use-study and adjustment clauses, board composition, dispute resolution steps and arbitration clauses shape both the claims and the forum.
  4. Protect the association in the meantime. When the controlling side cuts off records, blocks a new manager or sues to collect disputed assessments, interim relief and a clear record of the dispute matter as much as the eventual award.
  5. Recover and fix the structure. The goal is repayment and a governance change that stops the overcharges: independent accountants, audits, recusal of conflicted directors, and a new manager.

Signs worth a call

  • The developer, hotel owner or a commercial owner appoints a majority of the master board.
  • One component pays less than its percentage in the declaration, or none of the "allocated" expenses.
  • Affiliate invoices for labor or services arrive with little detail and are approved by affiliated directors.
  • The reserve study funds equipment or space the association does not own.
  • The association signed a no-bid contract with the developer or an affiliate.
  • There is no adopted budget, no reviewed financial statements, or no filed tax returns.
  • Records requests from directors or owners go unanswered.
  • A defect settlement was large, but the repairs have barely started.

Matters we do not handle

We do not take individual owner disputes over fines, violation notices, architectural approvals, parking, pets, noise, neighbor conflicts, or a single owner's assessment collection or lien. For those matters, the State Bar of California and The Florida Bar each run lawyer referral services.

Our experience

We were among class counsel in a federal class action for more than 250 purchasers of hotel-condominium units; the case ended in a $51 million settlement that received final approval in 2017. We were retained by the owners' association of a luxury fractional property to sue the developer's successors for breach of fiduciary duty and fraud after they used retained inventory to create a points-based product; the case resolved by settlement. See our representative cases and our class action practice.

Talk to us

For California matters, call (925) 256-0400 or email Michael J. Reiser at michael@reiserlaw.com. For Florida matters, call (305) 726-2003 or email Matthew W. Reiser at matthew@reiserlaw.com. It helps to have the master declaration and any sub-association declaration, the last two budgets, the reserve study, and a few representative invoices from the controlling owner or its affiliates. You can also use our contact page.

Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send confidential information until we have confirmed there is no conflict and agreed to represent you.